Triple Fisher: The Lethal Lolitas of Long Island

Noelle Parker

as Amy Fisher (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")

Drew Barrymore

as Amy Fisher (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")

Alyssa Milano

as Amy Fisher (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")

Ed Marinaro

as Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")

Tony Denison

as Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")

Jack Scalia

as Joey Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")

Kathleen Laskey

as Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")

Laurie Paton

as Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")

Phyllis Lyons

as Mary Jo Buttafuoco (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")

Boyd Kestner

as Paul Makely (archive footage from "Amy Fisher: My Story")

Philip Maurice Hayes

as Paul Makely (archive footage from "The Amy Fisher Story")

Michael Bowen

as Paul Makely (archive footage from "Casualties of Love")