A Christmas Wish

Hilarie Burton

as Faith

Megan Park

as Maddie

Cristián de la Fuente

as Andrew

Tyler Hilton

as Wyatt

Pam Grier

as Mary

Willie Garson

as Principal Wilson

Barbara Alyn Woods

as Marilyn

Lee Norris

as Ryan

Madeleine McGraw

as Stella

Rhoda Griffis

as Joyce

Antwon Tanner

as John

Bruce MacVittie

as Robert

Amy Brassette

as Elf

Rachel G. Whittle

as Tina

Ryan Cabrera

as Band Singer

May Badr

as Meg