For Better or For Worse: The Bestest Present

Billy Van

as Walter Lederhaus (voice)

Abby Hagyard

as Elly Patterson (voice)

Bill Stevens Jr.

as John Patterson (voice)

Scott Binkley

as John Patterson (singing voice)

Aaron Kim Johnston

as Michael Patterson (voice)

Katherine Johnston

as Elizabeth Patterson (voice)

Dominic Bradford

as Lawrence Poirier (voice)

Rod Johnston

as Mailman (voice)

Anna MacCormack

as Connie Poirier (voice) (uncredited)