The Witches They Couldn’t Burn

Caroline Grace

as Callie Baxter

Dante Genovesi

as Micah Carlson

Ava Genovesi

as Abigail Perkins

Thomas Burke Jr.

as Police Chief

Madeline Burke

as Teri Glover

Jake Lendall

as Carson’s Father

Bea Martin-Epstein

as Sarah Grey

Luke Menslage

as Young Carson

Alida Poirier

as June Baxter

Nicole Poirier

as Carson’s Mom

Wendell Poirier

as Carson McAllister

Brady Weed

as Drew Bailey